If Beale Street Could Talk

After MOONLIGHT I was gonna see the new Barry Jenkins movie no matter what. Didn’t have to ask what it was about. Probly wouldn’t sound like my thing anyway. If I had asked, the answer might’ve been something like “in early ’70s Harlem, a young woman and her family try to clear her fiance who has been falsely accused of rape.” But that would’ve been misleading because it’s not at all a thriller or a legal drama. There aren’t any plot twists or shocking revelations. We never see a courtroom. The background is the inescapable, self-perpetuating undertow of an unequal justice system, but the foreground is a story about love, not just between this couple but between them and their families.

Like MOONLIGHT it’s gorgeously lit and photographed by James Laxton (YOGA HOSERS), has thick mood and atmosphere, a strong sense of the character of its setting, and a cast full of revelatory performers, people you just want to be around, faces you want to (and get to) stare at in vivid closeup. The two lovers, Tish Rivers (KiKi Lane making a great debut) and Fonny Hunt (Stephan James, who played John Lewis in SELMA and Jesse Owens in RACE), absolutely beam with infatuation. We hear a little bit about them growing up as best friends, but we don’t need it. Their eyes tell us how enamored they are of each other.

But Fonny is, as Tish puts it, “behind glass” when she brings him news that they’re going to have a baby. And not for the last time we will hear firm assurances that things will be okay, people will stick together, odds will be overcome.

My favorite part of the movie is the next long stretch, like a one act play unto itself, where Tish goes home to tell her family she’s pregnant and they call over Fonny’s to tell them too. So much tension and humor about their differing reactions and the obvious dislike between the families. Imagine having Regina King (BOYZ N THE HOOD) as your mom! As Sharon she leans more Huey Freeman than Riley, and is a warm presence of strength and righteousness, here to support her daughter, future son-in-law and grandson-or-daughter in any way she can. And I immediately loved Tish’s dad Joe (Colman Domingo, Ralph Abernathy in SELMA, also in RED HOOK SUMMER), the jocular peacemaker. He uses his knack for male bonding to get Fonny’s dad Frank (Michael Beach, Black Manta’s dad in AQUAMAN) on board with Operation Support Our Grand Child. Frank makes us like him by being a check on his wife (Aunjanue Ellis, GAME OF DEATH, GET ON UP)’s judgmental qualities, but then does something that makes us gasp and wince. Also of note: Tish’s sister Ernestine (Teyonah Parris, Lysistrata from CHI-RAQ), who will prove to be very good at making colorful threats. You’ll see.

Another great part that kind of stands as its own little story is a flashback about Fonny randomly running into an old friend and inviting him over to the apartment to catch up. And the friend is played by Brian Tyree Henry, who I love mostly from Atlanta but also from WIDOWS and SPIDER-MAN: INTO THE SPIDER-VERSE and I’m gonna have to see HOTEL ARTEMIS and WHITE BOY RICK and he’s gonna be in the remake of CHILD’S PLAY and GODZILLA VS. KING KONG and eventually there’s gonna be a movie that he’s not in and we’re all gonna be like “what the fuck were they thinking not having Brian Tyree Henry in it?” Here he uses his great charisma powers and they laugh and pat each other on the shoulder and slowly make their way to talking about some real shit.

Jenkins adapted this one from James Baldwin’s fifth (and next-to-last) novel, published in 1974. The title comes from a lyric in the song “Beale Street Blues,” about the Memphis street that was a legendary hotbed of blues and jazz (and also, I discovered on my second visit, the location of King Jerry Lawler’s Hall of Fame Bar & Grille). A Baldwin quote that opens the film indicates that he was referring to a Beale Street in New Orleans where his father was born. Although nobody seems to be sure which specific street he was talking about, he uses it as a metaphor for every black neighborhood in the country. I wish I could say I was knowledgeable about his prose – that would be a lie, but they seem to come through in Tish’s narration and in the dialogue that occasionally uses terms that are either stylized or archaic, but always have a good sound to them.

These are really rich characters – lovable, not perfect, not always getting along, but instinctively pulling for each other. Like family. And it’s frustrating to see people who feel like your family stuck in this mess where – barring some thriller type twist that, I’ll go ahead and tell you, is not forthcoming – he seems to be quite clearly innocent. But even if it’s an easy case, just clearing it up costs money they don’t have, and takes time. So this kid comes into the world already a couple spaces behind on the Monopoly board because his early years are spent separate from his dad and minus the money spent on the case or that would’ve been earned by his dad. The biggest irony is that Tish and Fonny’s dads end up committing real crime to pay the lawyer (Finn Wittrock, NOAH) to prove Fonny didn’t commit a crime.

There’s a brief but important appearance of a racist cop (Ed Skrein, THE TRANSPORTER REFUELED). I’m impressed by his transformation, because I didn’t recognize him at all, but the way he struts in looking like some junkie low level mob weasel, ready to just start doing the racism, is the one thing about the movie I didn’t like. I mean I absolutely believe there are cops who would do what he does, but oozing sleaze like some character out of VICE SQUAD feels less true than the movie surrounding him. Could use more subtlety. But it’s a small thing.

I’ve heard of people dreading this one, under the assumption that it’s gonna be depressing. I think that comes out of a history of black American cinema and cinema about black America that focuses on misery and tragedy. And I think that comes partly out of a feeling of responsibility to the community, to keeping it real, to not wasting their platform. But I think this is very different from what those hesitant could-be-viewers might be picturing. It does address important and still relevant societal issues, but the emphasis is not on pain, victimhood or even injustice – it’s on the beauty of the people who must go on living despite those things. They support and inspire each other and they go out of their way – out of the country, even – to try to fix what’s wrong, but if that doesn’t work they will not be defeated or defined by it. So it’s sad, but it’s optimistic, and it’s strong. It says this is fucked up and I am outraged, but life is still full of love, and sex, and bottles of wine to share with friends, and pain that turns into laughter, and the sumptuous beauty of faces and polyester shirts and Harlem and soul music and movies like this that look and sound and feel so perfect they’re intoxicating.

This entry was posted on Monday, January 14th, 2019 at 12:10 pm and is filed under Drama, Reviews. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

5 Responses to “If Beale Street Could Talk”

  1. I’m never going to see this movie, so could someone answer a question for me? I’m a bit confused about how a movie in the day and age could be about the statistical anomaly and misogynist talking point of a false rape accusation and still be on the woke generation’s best-of list? This seems incongruous to me. Am I misreading this premise?

  2. Majestyk – I wondered the same thing early in the movie, but it’s not what you think. I’m not sure if this comes from the book or is an update, but SPOILER it’s made very clear that she really was raped but just doesn’t know who did it, and the police pushed her to choose out of a lineup someone they had a grudge against. The family members keep emphasizing that she really was raped, and there’s a very upsetting scene where Regina King’s character tries to talk to her about Fonny’s innocence and it forces her to relive the trauma of what happened, making everything worse. It paints a portrait of a justice system where everybody is being victimized and nobody is getting justice.

  3. The poetry in your review matches the poetry of this film. I left with a lump in my throat, from both the injustice and love portrayed. Regina King, oof. Man, after she confronts Victoria in Puerto Rico her reaction was so honest and brutal.

  4. It’s a beautiful and moving film. Despite some changes to the narrative, it’s more faithful to Baldwin’s book than one might expect in this era, so there are some very uncomfortable moments (particularly in that scene you highlighted wherein Tish announces her pregnancy to various family members). Thanks for your thoughtful review.

  5. That announcement and gathering scene might be the best scene of last year—it’s certainly on the shortlist.

    I didn’t love this as much as MOONLIGHT but it’s still damned good with lots of strong performances and heat checks. How the cinematographer got overlooked for the Oscars I’ll never understand.

Leave a Reply

XHTML: You can use: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>