I use hands to help my fellow man / I use hands to help with what I can / But when I face an unjust injury / Then I change my hand into FIST OF FURY

The Horse Whisperer

May 15, 1998

THE HORSE WHISPERER is a drama about healing and romance and horses. It’s pretty simple and intimate, focusing mainly on three characters, but it’s on an epic canvas; it’s nearly 3 hours long and it spreads out to widescreen when it moves from New York to the wide open fields of Montana, photographed lovingly by Robert Richardson (U-TURN, THE AVIATOR, DJANGO UNCHAINED).

Sixteen year old Grace (Scarlett Johansson in her followup to HOME ALONE 3) has a horrific horse-riding accident – I was actually unprepared for how fucked up the accident is – that results in the death of her best friend (Kate Bosworth [THE WARRIOR’S WAY, HOMEFRONT] in her first movie) and her friend’s horse, plus the loss of one of her legs and the mangling of her horse, Pilgrim. (This is the third movie of the summer where a semi-truck plowing into someone is a crucial plot point, but I don’t think this one involved a tired driver.) The experts want to put the horse out of his misery, but Grace’s mom Annie (Kristin Scott Thomas, UNDER THE CHERRY MOON) never gives permission, so he lives in a barn all scraped up and violently freaking out when approached. Grace is kind of the same, hating her mom and her life and breaking down when she sees Pilgrim scared of her.

But Annie reads a magazine article about this horse expert in Montana named Tom Booker (Robert Redford [THE HOT ROCK], his first time starring and directing at the same time). When she can’t get him to come to New York she packs up her daughter and horse against their will for a long drive conveyed through the medium of longer-than-expected driving montage. Grace dodges all attempts at conversation and bonding – thankfully the movie doesn’t give Annie any horse troubles on the trip. That would be a nightmare. I don’t know how helpful a horse whisperer is when your psychotic horse gets loose at a truck stop.

Annie is really the main character, which is interesting because she’s easily the least likable one. But she’s also the most complicated. I usually avoid the word “bitch,” but Annie starts out a classical movie version of that word. Her relationship with her daughter is so cold at first that I assumed she was the new, never-accepted stepmother. She’s designed to be grating from the very beginning – the parent who’s out of touch with her daughter, the wife who seems to care more about work than home and husband, the boss who bluntly tells everybody to do things over and leaves the whole staff barely concealing their looks of anger and frustration. On the ranch she causes a major episode when her cell phone causes Pilgrim to flip out, then she obliviously takes the call anyway. At dinner she embarrasses Grace with her talk to ranchers about all steaks tasting the same to her, unaware that she’s dismissing the hard work they do. She is hard to relate to.

Yet she’s the one who makes it happen. She refuses the conventional wisdom that the horse must be put down, stubbornly researches under the rich-person belief that there must be some expert out there you can pay to solve any problem. And she makes life a hell of alot harder for herself trying to work long distance while driving an unruly horse and daughter across the country believing – correctly – that this Tom guy can heal both of them. All three of them.

Do you think it’s weird that both Prince and Robert Redford directed themselves in romances with Kristin Scott Thomas? Do you think she’s proud of her heartthrob auteur track record?

As you’d imagine, this movie is about the glory of the simple country life. The old fashioned men and boys who wear hats and say “ma’am” and get up at dawn and work hard all day and stay up late by the campfire listening to an old cowboy play guitar and sing. Tom is pretty much the greatest man who ever lived – quiet, polite, gentle, empathetic and insightful to both animals and women. So of course over time she comes to be attracted to him. And things were not exactly dynamite at home with her husband Robert (Sam Neill, IN THE MOUTH OF MADNESS, HUNT FOR THE WILDERPEOPLE) otherwise she wouldn’t be able to just up and leave for months.

The romance elements are effective even though the whole idea of it had me cringing. Robert seems like the more reasonable of the two at the beginning of the movie, and it wasn’t his idea for them to be apart so long. There’s a long buildup to when Annie and Tom finally kiss and of course the next day Robert shows up at the ranch unexpectedly. Grace is absolutely thrilled to see him and luckily nobody bothers to look at Annie because she makes pretty much no attempt to hide the worry and discomfort and blue balls he’s causing by being around.

I honestly had to hide partly behind my hand like I was watching a cannibal movie when she slow danced crotch to crotch with Tom with Robert across the room chatting with the locals. (There’s a double-standard where everybody gathers around and is enraptured by his tales of adventure in the outside world, while they always seem to be politely humoring Annie if she mentions anything about her life).

Tom’s sister-in-law Dianne (Dianne Wiest, SYNECHDOCHE, NEW YORK) sees Annie sniffing around Tom and tries to warn her off. Dianne is the only one on the ranch who starts out suspicious and unwelcoming of this uninvited guest, but she’s not a bad guy – she’s right. And she’s nice enough to bond with Annie anyway. Her husband Frank (Chris Cooper, MONEY TRAIN)’s complete dismissal of her dream to travel to Morocco, and her acceptance of it, is the movie’s only strong argument against ranch life being a problem-free wonderland. When Annie defends city living by mentioning museums and theater and stuff she gets sort of shut down by the fact that Tom has experienced those things and still chose the ranch. When Grace looks disgusted by the ranchers pinning down cattle and branding them she’s won over by being made to help. The family’s jokes about city people being vegetarians who only eat salads never get any pushback. But it’s not too much of a conflict. There’s never much more tension than that awkward moment when dinner is served and you miss for a second that oh shit, yeah, they’re gonna pray first.

The first sign that Tom is “only a man,” as Dianne puts it, is when the camera lingers extra long on his hand pressing against Annie’s calf after helping her onto a horse. But upon further analysis this is not only signaling a sexual interest, but telling us his true purpose. When he first went to meet her about helping Pilgrim the camera showed him observing her restless leg shaking as she sat talking on the phone to someone from work. Now his hand reassures the leg much like it would a horse. It doesn’t hurt that she’s been completely removed from the job. He’s calming her just like he is the horse and Grace, and though he’ll be left behind by all three, hopefully his lessons will stay with them.

I think the long running time is really effective. By the end I really felt Annie’s reluctance to leave this place where everything is peaceful and different and she doesn’t have to go back to work. It’s like when you’re at the end of a vacation and you’re halfway convinced you just shouldn’t go home. She at least has been able to get a taste of a life she could’ve chosen if things were a little different.

THE HORSE WHISPERER is based on a 1995 book that sold over 15 million copies. It was the debut novel from English author Nicholas Evans. The adaptation is by Eric Roth (FORREST GUMP, THE POSTMAN, MUNICH) and Richard LaGravenese (THE FISHER KING, A LITTLE PRINCESS, THE BRIDGES OF MADISON COUNTY, BEHIND THE CANDELABRA). Judging from the summary on Wikipedia the movie they stayed pretty close to the book until it totally changes the ending. Listen to this (SPOILERS OBVIOUSLY), this sounds crazy compared to the movie:


Evans named Buck Brannaman, one of the horse trainers he met while researching the book, as the primary inspiration for Tom Booker, so Redford used him as the lead horse consultant and also as a double. So those are probly his hands we see calming the horses sometimes. There’s a documentary about Brannaman called BUCK, which I’ve heard is really good and which won an award at Sundance in 2011. Which is Redford’s festival. Hmm.

The Wikipedia entry is funny for how nitpicky it is about artistic license taken with horse training and psychology. For example it cites Booker wearing a ring while training a horse as “a risky practice in the real world when simultaneously handling a dangerous horse and a rope.” But of course it’s more likely that a viewer will note the story significance of him still wearing his wedding ring than that they will be endangered by an assumption that the movie is a flawless visual guide to horse whispering safety best practices. In my opinion.

Due to its setting and traditional clothing styles, most of the movie does not seem dated. The ranch, with its cowboy hats and “I don’t know how you do things in the big city” old timey family life, is intentionally timeless. But it has to be contrasted with the modernity of their life in New York, so that’s where most of the 1998 slips in. Annie has a fax machine, she uses an Alta Vista search. Grace has a Smashing Pumpkins poster and listens to Liz Phair, Pigeonhead and Sleater-Kinney. At one point Grace is watching 90210 on TV and Tom looks at Jason Priestley like he’s an alien making first contact. Also 1998 means that Annie having a cell phone is a character detail, a sign of her being a self-important bigshot type person. But once she stops using it she exists outside of time.

This will be the most normal grown up drama kind of thing I’ll have in this series, but it would be hard to beat. I guess the competition would be, like, HOPE FLOATS and THE LAND GIRLS? Maybe they’re good too. But the counter-programming seems to have worked okay. It opened second place under DEEP IMPACT (in its second week), above QUEST FOR CAMELOT, and it hung around for a while. In the long run it made more money than more pre-packaged entertainments like LOST IN SPACE, MERCURY RISING and THE AVENGERS. And I’m sure it’s remembered in a more positive light. At the very least it popularized the term “___ whisperer” as in “ghost whisperer,” “dog whisperer” or “ghost dog whisperer.” So it’s had more of an impact than Blarp. Sorry Blarp.

Thanks to Franchise Fred for encouraging me to watch this. Fingers crossed for HORSE WHISPERER 2.

NOTE: BULWORTH also came out on May 15, and I was totally gonna watch it again, but I looked at my review from 2009 and it seems pretty up to date. Some other time, Senator.

VERN has been reviewing movies since 1999 and is the author of the books SEAGALOGY: A STUDY OF THE ASS-KICKING FILMS OF STEVEN SEAGAL, YIPPEE KI-YAY MOVIEGOER!: WRITINGS ON BRUCE WILLIS, BADASS CINEMA AND OTHER IMPORTANT TOPICS and NIKETOWN: A NOVEL. His horror-action novel WORM ON A HOOK will arrive later this year.

This entry was posted on Monday, May 21st, 2018 at 8:31 am and is filed under Drama, Reviews. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

19 Responses to “The Horse Whisperer”

  1. Man, I was so excited to see a movie where Redford whispers to a horse. I was like: “Holy shit, I can’t wait till he whispers to the horse!” AND THEN HE TOTALLY WHISPERED TO THE HORSE! HOW AWESOME IS THIS!?

    But in all seriousness, I never saw it.

    However, horse riding is way more dangerous than people make it seem. A cousin of mine once fell down a horse and fucked up his hip and back so badly, that even after heavy surgery he couldn’t walk right.

  2. I have a hard time accepting these idealized odes to small town Americana now that I know most of these people were just waiting for an excuse to show the world how terrible they are. Just Vern’s descriptions of the smugness of the locals in this movie and the film’s tacit disapproval of Thomas because she GASP! has a career and opinions and standards (almost as if she thought she were a MAN and capable of generating those things on her own) is pissing me off. Yeah, I think I’ll continue skipping this one.

  3. Also that book ending sounds like the epitome of hot garbage. All recognizable human behavior thrown out they window in service of some bullshit literary aspiration. Pretty much my least favorite thing ever and proof of an author with his priorities in the wrong place and his head up his ass. Theme should follow story, not the other way around.

  4. This movie is really working last nerves, you guys. I might need a Majestyk Whisperer to calm me down.

  5. You should totally watch some episodes of the LETHAL WEAPON show or maybe the new STAR WARS movies, to calm you down, yo.

  6. I can attest to the documentary BUCK being really good. In fact, I think it’s better than this movie. It has zero of that judgy smugness that Majestyk is festering about. One time he gets mad at the way a woman let her horse get past the point of no return and it hurt one of his trainers. It was totally legit and he seems like an incredible guy.

    Also, Maj, I don’t know if it had much effect on the book’s ending, but I know Redford bought the movie rights before the book was even finished, so the guy was all, oh shit, I need to get this done! Still, no excuse for it, but maybe an explanation.

  7. I was having an experience similar to Majestyk as I read this review. I also think it’s kind of funny that Hollywood is so often represented as out of touch with the middle part of this country when they routinely put out movies that extol the virtues of hard working country folk who need to teach these city people a thing or two.

  8. I know, right? Every screenwriter who ever lived couldn’t fucking WAIT to get out of their shitty hometown full of close-minded morons and move to the big city where their talent would finally be recognized. Then as soon as they get there they start writing peons to all the saintly countryfolk back home. As somebody whose made the journey there and back again, I can tell you this: There are goods and bads in both settings, and they could both learn a little something from each other. But you ever see a movie about that?

  9. Since I’m one of the most ‘country’ of those that post here let me try and defend my birthright by saying ‘They are good people… as long as you ignore the latent racism, Fox News agreeing…’ Hey I’m trying okay..

    I saw this when it came out on VHS and remember liking it, don’t remember the lead being an asshole though, but I have not seen it since.

    And you’re good skipping HOPE FLOATS.

    ‘I might need a Majestyk Whisperer to calm me down.’
    *places hand on a watermelon to sooth the nerves and communicate.

  10. Mr Majestyk, in SHOOT TO KILL Sidney Poitier’s big city FBI agent and Tom Berenger’s mountain guide both know useful stuff and teach each other a lesson. Good movie too.

  11. That’s an excellent point. I should watch SHOOT TO KILL again.

  12. The Winchester

    May 21st, 2018 at 5:54 pm

    I would pay good money to see Ghost Dog Whisperer: Way of the Samurai

  13. I liked the sequel where it turns out Tom faked his death in that stampede and got a top government job as part of a plan he hatched in his militia days to overthrow the government and kill lots of people. Unfortunately for him, Grace went on to get a job working for a top secret spy agency and was totally onto him and foiled everything. Then Samuel L. Jackson shot him.

  14. In terms of 98 Summer(ish) counter-programmers I was hoping (though please don’t take this as in any way a criticism) that CITY OF ANGELS would be featured, as it knocked LOST IN SPACE off the top spot. Aside from the obvious Cage factor it’s just a film I’m quite fond of. Yes, it’s not WINGS OF DESIRE (points even from its harshest critics, surely, for not rehashing the title?), but in terms of Hollywood romances and/or spiritually focused films I find it to be a tasteful, thoughtful and just very enjoyable film. The better of the two big budget Hollywood CITY OF ANGELS I dare say.

  15. I’ll second that. Hope you review CITY OF ANGELS Vern.

  16. So glad you liked it Vern. I had a harsh reaction to Annie in ‘98 but now I see all the things she does despite her flaws: saving the horse, driving to Tom’s without his permission. Her tough love approach doesn’t work but she takes the time to change the essence of a woman.

    The book actually goes into too much detail about how tired and sleep-deprived the truck driver was. It’s unnecessary detail.

    I remember Hope Floats being good too. Seemed like a mature depiction of divorce but I don’t remember it as well.

  17. The Winchester

    May 22nd, 2018 at 9:53 am

    For this series, does Last Days of Disco or Opposite of Sex count as counter programming blockbusters?

    I remember reading this book called The Gross (I think) where Peter Bart analyzed each weekend of this summer and what it meant. I would love to see an updated take on that book now, but I remember thinking when I read it how crappy the movies seemed, but now I realize how much interesting stuff came out then.

  18. I spent a fair amount of time in Montana in my younger days. Mr. Majestyk is not totally off-base with his assessment of the citizenry. The term “R**skin” was thrown around pretty regularly in those days, and it was not, despite what a certain NFL owner would have you believe, meant to be laudatory.

  19. Mr. Majestyk – I visited family in rural North Carolina last Thanksgiving, up in these beautiful mountains.

    And while driving past this barn that could have been from a post card what do I see hanging on it? A TRUMP PENCE sign a year after the election (never spotted any MAGA hats though)

    But I still really enjoyed my time there, you got to take the good with the bad and there is really something eerily beautiful about these places, looking at misty hills at dawn and listening to the dead silence, there’s an almost supernatural/spiritual vibe to it, especially for a guy like me who spends so little time in nature.

    So I can see why Hollywood likes to make odes to small town America and it’s also important to remember times are still changing, in the heart of the downtown area of this small Americana town, at this little bookstore there was still a decent manga selection, including CITRUS, which is about lesbians.

    So manga lesbians in the heart of rural Americana, interesting sign of the times.

Leave a Reply





XHTML: You can use: <a href="" title=""> <img src=""> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <b> <i> <strike> <em> <strong>