So once again we have survived.

Heroes of the East

tn_heroesoftheeastaka CHALLENGE OF THE NINJA, SHAOLIN VS. NINJA, SHAOLIN CHALLENGES NINJA

HEROES OF THE EAST is a really top notch Shaw Brothers production that’s half all-time classic martial arts movie, half romantic comedy. There are cultural differences that separate it from a Katherine Heigl movie besides just martial arts, the main one being arranged marriage. In a Heigl picture she’s forced to be with a guy she initially hates because of a baby, here it’s because of powerful Chinese and Japanese business families trying to expand their reach by making their kids marry each other.

mp_heroesoftheeastGordon Liu is Ah To, the Chinese son. It’s a real different character from the monks he plays in 36TH CHAMBER OF SHAOLIN and 8-DIAGRAM POLE FIGHTER. He’s much more priveleged, he has servants, he has hair. And it’s the modern world, he wears a tie sometimes.

Anyway Kung Zi (Yuka Mizuno) is his Japanese bride, and there’s a little misunderstanding where his servant – I feel weird saying that, let’s call it his assistant – hears her behind closed doors practicing karate and thinks he’s beating her. Don’t worry, the assistant takes it seriously and reports it to Ah To’s father, which causes some embarrassment. But when the truth comes out it becomes a household battle between karate and kung fu, Japan and China. She keeps breaking everything in the backyard with her kicks and chops so they move her into the practice hall, but she has all the Chinese weapons moved out and replaced with Japanese ones.

At first I sided with the wife. The husband seems real uptight and sexist. He gets real upset about her boobs showing when she wears her gi. He also shows her a kung fu style for women to use so that their legs stay closed. It’s completely ridiculous, it looks like he has to piss real bad. So I felt like I understood why she was fighting with this guy and trying to piss him off. But then she just keeps pushing him and she starts to seem like she’s taking it too far and I go back to his side.

The argument escalates to sparring, next thing you know they’re throwing hidden knives and darts at each other to demonstrate the superiority of their respective nations’ traditional weaponry. It’s a funny kung fu WAR OF THE ROSES but the argument comes to a head when she brags about ninjitsu and he says of course Chinese people could use that type of trickery, but they don’t believe in it, they believe in honorable fights and think that ninja shit is only for “treacherous villains.”

And that point causes a serious bump in the marriage. Remember when your parents would fight and your mom would pack a suitcase and not say which motel she was going to? Kung Zi does the exact same thing as your mom, assuming your mom went back to Japan to complete her ninja training with a handsome ninja she’s likely to fall in love with because she grew up very close to him and he’s played by Yasuaki Kurata, the old Japanese master in that classic earn-each-other’s-respect fight in FIST OF LEGEND.

Of course this is when Ah To realizes how much he cares about her, so romantic comedy tradition dictates that he must perform some sort of trickery to deceive her into interacting with him so he can get her to love him again. Not necessarily pull a full-on Mrs. Doubtfire, but he’s gotta somehow lie to her so that he can straighten it out at the end, right? Well, his assistant has a good one: send her a challenge letter. Her pride will force her to come home for a duel and then he can say no baby, come on, I don’t really want to have a sword fight, we belong together, etc.

The only problem is she’s training with the five greatest masters of each major Japanese martial art, so they read the letter like What the fuck!? This guy thinks China is better than Japan? And he’s gonna prove it by beating up his wife? No fucking way. We’re going. So this letter that was supposed to win him his wife back instead forces him to fight five masters. That’s the second half of the movie: one fight per day until he beats them all. Kung Zi actually feels bad about it so she joins him as his interpreter as he tries to defeat them all.

The director is Chia-Liang Liu, who also did the aforementioned 36TH CHAMBER and 8-DIAGRAM, and like those it finds excuses for Gordon Liu to fight in a whole bunch of different styles and with a whole bunch of different weapons. He does get to use the 3-section staff again (against nunchakas – his opponent announces that H To wins because his weapon is longer). There’s a kitana vs. a Chinese double-edged long sword, there’s karate vs. drunken kung fu, etc.

Every one of the fights is great and different from the last. He’s supposed to be kind of pushing it, cramming to master each of the Chinese styles before each duel, but we know he’s Gordon Liu so we don’t believe he doesn’t already know it. But he has to use cunning (or trickery) in some of these things. One that seems like almost a cheat is when the Japanese grappler is kicking his ass but Ah To’s assistant lubes him up with peanut oil so the guy can’t get a grip on him. That trick is still used to this day though in mixed martial arts.

The sword fight is a classic, but I think my favorite is the climactic ninja duel. They use all the techniques: disguises, decoy dummies, padded clothing, throwing stars, sleeve arrows, back darts, throwing knives, smoke bombs, spiderhole, underwater stealth, spitting poison, faking death, and more.

Somebody recommended this one to me, I wasn’t sure if it was gonna be up my alley, but I absolutely loved it. You could say we were in an arranged marriage and fell in love. Okay, I can’t really relate to that part of the story in my culture. You know what Disney’s ALADDIN said about arranged marriage. It’s against it. Despite that the themes in the movie are universal. It’s about stubbornness in relationships between men and women, and between countries. They never stop and listen to each other, they’re so insistent on proving their own points. I know it has too many titles already, but another good one would be DUEL OF THE SHOW-OFFS. Because of their egos they’re not gonna just talk things out if it prevents them from busting out a couple more weapons and showing them off.

Because they refuse to be diplomatic they cause an international incident, and because they don’t take the time to learn each other’s customs they make it even worse. There’s a great turn of events where the samurai offers him his sword as a sign of respect but he doesn’t pick up on it at all and manages to completely insult him and make the masters even more pissed. His wife explains to him later that if he would’ve taken it he would’ve squashed the whole beef. No such luck.

But the thing is, Ah To & Kung Zi and Ah To & the masters obviously love showing each other their different techniques. They do a move or a style or pull out a weapon and they announce what it is, sometimes they offer a little explanation. In their minds they’re competing but in a sense they’re also doing show and tell. They’re sharing their cultures with each other, they just don’t realize it.

This is gonna be a SPOILINGS, but another reason why I love this movie is that it’s one of these stories where they angrily fight each other but end up accidentally bonding. There are plenty of kung fu movies, including classics like FIST OF FURY, that come across very nationalistic. This one shoots that kind of thinking down. Nobody kills each other and at the end they’re all friends. It’s a romantic, feel good, ass-kicking kung fu and karate masterpiece. SHAOLIN LOVES AND RESPECTS NINJA.

VERN has been reviewing movies since 1999 and is the author of the books SEAGALOGY: A STUDY OF THE ASS-KICKING FILMS OF STEVEN SEAGAL, YIPPEE KI-YAY MOVIEGOER!: WRITINGS ON BRUCE WILLIS, BADASS CINEMA AND OTHER IMPORTANT TOPICS and NIKETOWN: A NOVEL. His horror-action novel WORM ON A HOOK will arrive later this year.
This entry was posted on Friday, November 12th, 2010 at 1:51 pm and is filed under Action, Martial Arts, Reviews, Romance. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

16 Responses to “Heroes of the East”

  1. God , YES !! You finally reviewed this !! It’s one of my favorite movies of all times and I’m glad you’ve seen it ! Now ( even if it’s not this open minded ) , Vern , you must see Chinese Super Ninjas !

  2. I don’t remember when exactly , but a couple of years ago when you did a revival of the Badass Awards ( maybe I’ve got some problems here , but I can’t find it anymore on the site , the tab up there only opens up the home page again for me ), I included Heroes of the East in my list of Badass Movies . It’s that good . I remember when you reviewed Enter the Ninja , writing that Kosugi was showing-off every weapon right there in the opening , and I was immediately thinking about this movie , because the number of weapons and martial arts on display here is just ridiculous . The best in my opinion is the fight with the little guy with the knives and all the Drunken Kung Fu stuff . Truly a masterpiece and by far my favorite Gordon Liu movie. I wish every romantic comedy was this good.

  3. Outstanding Shaw Brothers joint, and to compare & associate it with my beloved FIST OF LEGEND is apt & rightly reverential for each of the 2 films.

    Vern said it all, I reckon. Great fights that make you wish there was still a studio & cadre of badasses that picked up there [sometimes plastic] weapons and went to work during daylight hours making kung fu/karate/ninja nonfatal (SPOILER) movie magic.

    Nothing to add here now except, “Roger that. Have I made my woman watch this with me yet? I need to get on that.”

  4. Vern – Now go review that John Frakenheimer ninja flick THE CHALLENGE.

  5. The one with the fight between knives and garden forks and the guy with the garden forks has a super fast twitch? Outstanding movie.

  6. I’d also recommend FLAG OF IRON. Rule of thumb here – if the Wu Tang named an album after it, it’s a good one.

  7. Great review as always, Vern! I already review this one myself a few months ago, and I’m glad you loved it too. I have to ask, and I pointed it out in my review, tell me that Sai master doesn’t remind you of an Asian Prince! Even the way he appears in the cart for the fight…

  8. I wouldn’t say this movie isn’t nationalistic. After all, the Chinese arts prove “superior” since this rich Han snob was able to beat all the Japanese masters. Despite that though the movie has one thousand times more humanity than any other HK-produced “China is better than barbarous Japan” film so if you going to watch just one of these, I would recommend this over all others.

  9. Whoa! Mr. Charles Bronson with the recko.

    Did you learn all this from Michael Winner, or has your ghost been chatting with Asian culture connoisseur Steven Seagal lately?

  10. Sounds really good. Looking it up though, and there’s no Region 2 DVD release for it. Bummer.

  11. This movie sounds ABAR.

    (Awesome Beyond All Reason.)

    Will definitely hunt it down and add to the collection.

  12. Oh shit! This spambot has discovered the secret to boldfaced text! We’re doomed!

  13. This puts me in the mood for some Shaw Brothers action, so you might find it worth a listen:

    http://soundcloud.com/theavclub/wu-tang-clan-laced-cheeba

  14. Movies don’t get much better than this.

    Lau Kar-leung’s mortality, I’m certain, is a fakeout. Any second now, he’ll pop up from the grave, explain his innovative deep-breathing anti-leukemia technique, shake hands with his adversaries, and laugh away his apparent corpsitude.

  15. So I checked this one out based on the recommendations and out of respect for the fallen master. Sadly, I gotta be the party pooper on this one, guys. The fights are all amazing, of course, but doesn’t anybody else have a problem with a romantic comedy that forgets about its leading lady halfway through? This was not supposed to be the story of how one Chinese dude wins the respect of a bunch of Japanese dudes. It was about how a Chinese guy and a Japanese woman learn to respect each other’s differences through the medium of kung fu. Except that didn’t happen. A soon as the masters showed up, the movie lost all interest in the wife character. She just lets all these men fight her battles for her while she slinks back to her husband and doesn’t even resolve anything. She’s not even in the last four or five scenes! It’s great that Lui and the masters all became fight brothers, but that’s not really the point, is it? What kind of understanding did he and his wife come to? Can she practice karate in the house without him being a prick about it? Will they continue sparring now that he respects Japanese martial arts? I have no idea since the wife disappears from the picture. Clearly, she was just a plot device to get the masters to China. Once she’s served that purpose, the movie loses all interest in her. I’m glad the movie dealt with its jingoism, but it still has a ways to go in its sexism. The movie seems to assume that we’re all gonna be psyched that Kung Zi learned her place by her man’s side, even though he did nothing to deserve it.

    Actually, I gotta call bullshit on the jingoism, too. The movie pretends it’s being even-handed, yet I’m supposed to believe that some coddled rich dude in a fancy suit can defeat all of the greatest masters of Japan, guys who spend their entire lives doing nothing else but practice martial arts? The only way I’d buy that is if they beefed up the love story and made me believe that he won because he got that extra oomph from fighting for love, except the movie had already abandoned that angle. There was no sense that he had to win these fights to get his wife back, since she’d already acquiesced and didn’t even call him on his bullshit. She just took his side while he had his macho little tournament that had fuck-all to do with their relationship. The movie took an interesting story about a relationship between a man and a woman and turned it into a pissing contest between the men in her life. She started the story as a feisty, opinionated woman, but she ended it on the sidelines, having no effect on the outcome of what was supposed to be her own story.

    Great fights, though.

  16. I can´t fault Mr Majestyks complaints here but otherwise this is my kind of romantic comedy.

Leave a Reply





XHTML: You can use: <a href="" title=""> <img src=""> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <b> <i> <strike> <em> <strong>